Renting a car in Europe can be expensive -- as much as 40
percent higher than renting in the US. Add the high cost of
gasoline, highway tolls, and value-added taxes of 17 percent
or more, and having your own set of wheels becomes a pricey
proposition. There are also airport taxes to consider if you're
picking up your rental from the airport -- as well as steep
parking fees in urban areas.
Having said that, however, there's no better way to explore
the European countryside than in a car.
If you're traveling solo, seeing Europe by car is a luxury --
budget travelers should consider trains. But if you're traveling
with a companion or family, driving becomes more affordable
and allows both door-to-door accessibility and the freedom to
come and go at will. Renting can be tricky for first-timers,
however. Pricing, choosing a rental company, and deciding
where to book your rental are issues you'll want to decide
ahead of time. And keep your credit card handy. This is one
situation where understanding card-member benefits could
save you money on costly insurance coverage.
We asked Contributing Editor Susan Weissman to research this
complicated subject and tell you how to get the best deal with
the most coverage when renting in Europe.
The players
There are lots of players in the game. Familiar names like Hertz
and Avis can provide you with a car outside the US, but don't
assume you'll get the same competitive rates you'd get back
home. That doesn't mean European rental companies like
Kemwell or Thermeon will cost any less. Generally, renting
through big-name companies is the most expensive way to go.
Compare prices by also checking out consolidators --
companies that negotiate volume discounts with rental car
companies, such as National and Hertz -- that can sometimes
pass savings of 30 percent or more on to consumers.
Other advantages to renting through a consolidator include
more cars to choose from since the fleet is bigger; more
locations for pickup and drop-off; unrestricted driving in high-
risk countries like Italy and Ireland (Mercedes and other luxury
cars excluded); and greater flexibility in insurance coverage
and age restrictions. You can even rent specialty vehicles such
as luxury cars, SUVs, and motorhomes. EuroDrive and
AutoEurope both offer affordable cell phone rental and infant
seats.
Where to initiate rental
To get your best deal, book your rental from the US before
leaving for Europe. Rates are far better than what you'll
encounter if you arrange things after you arrive, and your price
will be quoted in dollars. So even if currency fluctuations turn
against you, you're protected.
Don't worry if your plans change. Consolidators such as
AutoEurope and EuroCar allow you to lock in a price and cancel
without penalty 24 hours before pickup. To guarantee your
rental, most consolidators require a deposit equivalent to 30
to 50 percent of the rental fee. Once you've put down a
deposit, and to avoid confusion when you're thousands of
miles from home, make sure you get confirmation in writing.
Carry the document with you when you claim your car.
Advance reservations from the US, however, can't be made for
rentals in Eastern Europe -- you'll have to finalize
arrangements upon arrival.
Expect soaring costs for theft coverage in countries like the
Czech Republic, Albania, Rumania, Poland, and Hungary. Italy
has the highest rate of car theft in Europe, so don't get any
romantic thoughts about renting a convertible Mercedes in
Naples to cruise the Amalfi Coast. If you want to drive in Italy,
consider renting in a neighboring country such as Germany,
France, or Switzerland. That way, insurance coverage provided
by most premium credit cards will be in force. Some cards
exclude Italian rentals from coverage, but if you rent at, say,
the airport in Geneva, you're covered even if you spend the
rest of your vacation driving in Italy. In troubled spots such as
Bosnia, Herzegovina, and Croatia, you may not be able to rent
at all depending upon the political situation when you visit.
We couldn't find any company (American or European) in the
States willing to rent cars in Turkey, one of the most
dangerous countries in the world for driving. Nor can you take
a rental car on a ferry in Europe or on the Chunnel and have
your insurance remain in force.
What to rent
If "give me the cheapest thing you've got" are usually the first
words out of your mouth, you may want to rethink your choice
when renting a car in Europe. With the average speed on
French peages, Italian autostradas, and German autobahns
close to 80 miles an hour, and driver aggression on the plus
side of intense, you might not want to explore unknown lands
in a car that looks like a Matchbox toy. But do try to strike a
happy medium. A big car may prove burdensome in towns
where parking is scarce and streets are winding and narrow.
Your best choice is a compact or full-size sedan.
The next question: manual or standard transmission? If you
can drive a stick, you'll save 30 to 40 percent. The other
advantage to renting a car with a manual transmission is
better gas mileage and better handling. On winding mountain
roads, you'll be thankful when your car dutifully climbs the
mountain -- leaving the automatics grinding in its wake.
The last consideration is air-conditioning. Few places in Europe
get as hot as most places in the States during the summer.
The exceptions are the areas nearest the Mediterranean:
southern France, Italy, Spain, and Portugal. Of course, part of
the fun of vacationing on the Mediterranean is the sensuality
of the environment. You won't experience much of that as you
meander through the lavender fields of Provence with the
windows sealed tight.
When and where to pick up your wheels
Rates are cheapest when you observe the following:
- Pick up and return your rental on weekends.
- The longer the length of the rental, the cheaper the rate.
- Try to avoid renting in Italy, Austria, or Eastern Europe.
- Pickup and return to the airport can be more costly than
pickup and return to other locations (this is not always the
case, so ask).
- Where it's available, rent a diesel because you'll pay less for
fuel.
Protecting your rental
Insurance is complicated when you rent in Europe. Don't
expect to hand over your VISA and have your credit card
company provide the same coverage it offers in the States.
Premium cards -- gold and platinum versions of VISA,
Mastercard, and American Express -- are your best bets. Check
your cardholder's agreement before you book to see what
countries might be excluded from coverage with the card you
carry.
If you can't find that small-type agreement you received when
you first got your credit or charge card, request a copy and
carry it with you, especially if you'll be traveling in Ireland,
Italy, or Eastern Europe. It is not enough to say that your
credit card company provides sufficient coverage if your rental
is demolished or stolen. The extent of coverage provided by
credit cards varies and is usually subject to certain restrictions
like the length of rental and the type of vehicle you rent. And
ask your credit card company whether your card covers drivers
other than the specific cardholder.
If you're lucky enough to be in Europe for 17 days or more,
look into Renault's Buy/Lease program[www.eurodrive.renault.com]. It's hands-down the
best deal for long-term rental. Bundled in the cost of your new
car -- yes, you buy it and return it -- is insurance. This special
situation has the additional benefit of exemption from VAT
taxes. Other incentives include a factory-fresh car, the lowest
rates of any rental program or consolidator providing cars in
Europe, delivery and return to more locations, 24-hour
roadside assistance, and very few restrictions as to where you
can take the car. You can also choose a diesel to cut down on
the cost of fuel. Sound like a flaky deal? Not really. The
program has been around since the '80s. Nothing's cheaper if
you'll need wheels for more than 17 days. We were quoted
just under $400 for the rental of a compact car for 17 days
during the first week in August.
Whatever you opt for, when you're abroad, take driving
seriously. The "rules of the road" take on new meaning in
distant lands. And don't forget to ask if there's a discount for
AARP or AAA club members.
What to Ask, Whom to Ask
- Are there age limitations for drivers?
- Is an advanced deposit required to reserve a vehicle? If you
cancel your reservation, is your deposit refunded without
penalty? How far in advance must you give notice? If there is a
penalty, what is it?
- Are you permitted to change pickup and drop-off locations
without incurring an alteration or cancellation charge?
- Are airports taxes included in the quoted price if you're
picking up your rental at the airport?
- Is there a surcharge for additional drivers?
- Do you receive unlimited mileage?
- Is it advantageous to return your vehicle with a full tank of
gas?
- Does your rental agreement exclude driving in certain
countries (of the former USSR, say, and Eastern Europe,
Turkey, Italy or Ireland)?
- Does the rental company guarantee you'll receive the car of
your choice? If not, will the cost of the rental be adjusted?
- If you opt for insurance coverage through your credit card
company, will a hold be placed on your card to insure you can
pay should damage to the vehicle occur? Some companies will
put the entire cost of a car on a credit card at the time of
rental, which means your card might be rejected as being
"over limit" the next time you try to use it.
Consolidators
Auto Europe, www.autoeurope.com, 888-223-5555
Europcar, www.europcar.com, 877-940-6900
Rental Companies in the US
Avis, www.avis.com, 800-230-4898
Hertz, www.hertz.com, 800-654-3131
Rental Companies in Europe
Kemwell, www.kemwel.com, 877-820-0668
Thermeon,
www.thermeoneurope.com/carsplus/index.html ,
800-977-1040
Staying Safe When You Drive Abroad
Consult the State Department warnings before you explore
unknown territory: http://travel.state.gov/road_safety.html.
Pricing: A Real-Life Comparison
The information that follows is based on a seven-day rental
with pickup from and delivery to Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport
from Aug. 3-10, 2002. Adding an additional driver costs $2
per day from AutoEurope and EuroDrive and a flat $18 fee
from Avis and Hertz. All mileage is unrestricted.
AutoEurope
Compact A/C (Manual)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $223.65; with insurance, $294.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe
Full Size A/C (Automatic)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $529.20; with insurance, $919.01
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe or Italy
EuroDrive
Compact A/C (Manual)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $289.57; with insurance, $348.51
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe
Full Size A/C (Automatic)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $759.00; with insurance, $1,059.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe
Avis
Compact A/C (Manual)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $243.00; with insurance, $331.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe
Full Size A/C (Automatic)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $898.00; with insurance, $1,311.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe or Italy
Hertz
Compact A/C (Manual)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $265.00; with insurance, $339.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe
Full Size A/C (Automatic)
Airport fees/taxes: $20 airport tax; $10 road tax
Cost per seven days: $901.00; with insurance, $1,264.00
Restrictions: No driving in E. Europe or Italy
June 2002